- The US Federal Reserve cuts its cash interest rate by 0.50%.
- Inflation is now largely contained, the US is cutting interest rates – Australia however, is still ‘on hold’.
- Share markets were buoyed by the first US interest rate cut and solid economic data.
- China embarked on further stimulus – their share market rallied strongly on the news.
The Big Picture
Asset Classes
International Equities
The US S&P 500 share index and its equally-weighted version, both reached all-time highs after the Fed interest rate cut. The S&P 500 was up +2.0% on the month. Since the ‘magnificent seven’ stocks dominated the first half gains in the broader index, it is encouraging to see the gains spread to a broader range of companies.
China’s Shanghai Composite was up +17.4% (including +8.5% on the last day of September – a 16-year record) and Emerging Markets were up +5.7%. The Nikkei was looking at a strong month until the new prime minister sparked interest rate hike fears brought the index down -4% in one day and more at the open on the last day of September. The Nikkei finished down -1.9% on the month.
The US Fed has been the focus of our attention even though a number of other central banks had already started cutting their interest rates. A 0.50% cut by the Fed was taken very positively in both equity and bond markets. Since most US mortgages are written as 30-year fixed term loans, we do not expect a big bounce in consumer expenditure in the US. If mortgage rates do start to fall, mortgagees in the US can refinance with no penalty if they had taken the loan out at recent higher interest rates.
The market and the RBA are at odds with each other. The markets (and us) think that there is a reasonable chance of an interest rate cut in November or December whereas the RBA is still talking in terms of no cuts this year. Three of the big four banks state that they see the first cut in February next year. However, pricing tools based on derivative markets imply a material chance of an interest rate cut this year.
The Bank of England was on hold in September after its first interest rate cut in four years at its prior meeting. The UK’s latest monthly inflation read did rise from +2.0% to +2.2%.
The Bank of Canada has already cut its interest rate three times in this cycle. Switzerland, the ECB and Sweden have also cut more than once. Norway is perhaps the only other ‘major’ central bank not to have yet commenced policy easing.
We do not see any evidence of a worrying build-up of wage or producer price inflation in the economies of the countries that we follow. China has just made a number of easing moves in an attempt to stimulate the economy which is in danger of not keeping up with government growth forecasts. We think that the current paradigm of cutting interest rates around the world has a lot of merit.
Other Assets
Iron ore prices dipped below $US100 per tonne but recovered towards the end of the month – up +9.6% on the month. China eased home lending restrictions and iron ore prices popped +9% on September 30th.
Crude oil prices Brent and West Texas Intermediate (WTI) were down sharply at around -9% and -8%, respectively.
The price of gold is on a charge as it gained +5.1% on the month.
The price of copper was also up sharply at +8.0% for September.
The VIX ‘fear’ index, a measure of US share market volatility, was back to a ‘normal’ range at 13.1 but then closed the month at 16.7 on the last day.
The Australian dollar appreciated against the US dollar by +1.9%.
Regional Review
We saw several reports in September extolling the strength of our jobs market because 47,000 jobs had been created. Delving only slightly deeper into the report, we noted that full-time employment went down by more than -3,000 jobs. Part-time jobs made up the difference. Our unemployment rate was reported as 4.2%.
June quarter economic growth data were published this month. Our economy only grew by 0.2% this quarter which became -0.4% when adjusted for population growth. Over the year, growth was 1.0% and per capita growth was -1.5%. That result made for the fifth successive quarter of negative per capita growth – and extended the per capita recession by most people’s definition.
Our monthly CPI read looked good in both headline (+2.7%) and core (+3.0%) but we have issues in the way the ABS has addressed the electricity subsidy. A lump sum subsidy is not a price change but the ABS treated it so. Electricity price inflation was reported as a fall of -17.9% over the year. As soon as the subsidy is removed, electricity inflation must spring back to near prior levels unless something else impacts prices.
RBA Governor Bullock stressed in her post board-meeting press conference that one good number wouldn’t budge her on rates. We agree with that view but keeping rates high does not impact positively on CPI inflation. It is time to focus on the other of the RBA’s policy responsibilities – employment.
The China Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) for manufacturing still seemed stuck at just below the ‘50’ mark at 49.1 from 49.4 for August (at the start of September) but it bounced back to 49.8 at the end of the month.
Exports were strong at +8.7% but imports only recorded growth of +0.5%. CPI inflation was +0.6% against an expected +0.7%.
Retail sales grew by +2.1% following +2.7% the previous month. Industrial output rose +4.5% following +5.1% in the prior month.
These generally weaker numbers appeared to have pushed the government into trying to stimulate growth in China’s economy. The People’s Bank of China (PBOC), unlike most other central banks, uses a variety of instruments to help guide its direction. An unusually large number of ‘levers’ were pulled in September to affect a more stimulatory environment. It is difficult to assess what the aggregate response by the economy will be. What we can reasonably say is, now that they have started stimulating the economy with a purpose, if more stimulus is needed, they will do what it takes to achieve their objectives.
US
The contest between presidential candidates Harris and Trump is still tight in the sports-betting markets. Harris is just ahead but Trump has taken a couple of brief turns in front in the recent past.
There seems to be lots of bias in how analysts judge the candidates’ policies. Left-leaning analysts write of the inflationary consequences of Trump. For example, the removal of 8 million-plus illegal immigrants would cause massive disruption but they would first have to find them and then the means to remove them. Assessing the amount of actual disruption to growth and inflation is fraught with severe difficulties.
With regard to Harris’ policies, we have not seen too much in terms of detail or costings. Giving free medical insurance to all illegal immigrants and more is not apparently funded. Obama failed with Obamacare so what chance dealing with illegals? Similarly, Harris’s $50k automatic tax deduction for start-ups sounds great but we have seen no costings.
Apparently, the election result is forecast to turn on three key states and there is an inherent bias towards the Republicans in the electoral college. Although everyone is entitled to express an opinion in a democracy here or in the US, we suspect the election outcome is all too close to call.
US jobs improved from the low 89,000 figure reported in August to 142,000 in September. The unemployment rate went down from 4.3% to 4.2%. But there are some anomalies in the component pieces of the labour market puzzle. Powell is obviously concerned but we think he is well aware of the situation.
The Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index fell from 105.6 to 98.7.
The US has three important sets of inflation data released each month. Since, in essence, the Fed has declared the inflation fight is of secondary importance, if not over, suffice it to write here that there were no disturbing features in this month’s plethora of inflation data. The Fed has accepted the position we have held for quite some time. But what if the Middle East conflict ramps up? We can’t predict that or any consequences. Investing is a process of dealing with risk as it becomes apparent.
Europe
The UK economy put in two successive months of 0% growth or +0.5% for June quarter. This followed the +0.7% growth rate in the March quarter. Its inflation read went up from +2.0% to +2.2% so the BoE was ‘on hold’ this month.
The ECB is dealing with a weakening eurozone economy but it cut for a second time in this cycle to deal with the problem. There are lags in the system but cutting interest rates now is better than not cutting at all.
Rest of the world
The Israeli conflict is apparently expanding into Lebanon with no real signs of a solution in sight. Thus far, there has not been a material spillover into instability in major financial markets. Iran doesn’t seem keen to get involved.
Canada’s inflation, at 2%, is the slowest since February 2021. It has now made its third cut in interest rates. Its unemployment rate climbed to +6.6% in August – up from +5% in early 2023.
Japan changed PM in a fresh election and, with fears of interest rate rises, the Nikkei opened down -4% on September 30th.